top of page

The Culture You Tolerate Is the Culture You Create

Nov 4, 2024
3 min read

Updated: Sep 28

Culture isn't created by the values written on a wall. It is created by the behaviors people experience every day—and by what leaders reinforce, ignore, challenge, and allow.

One leadership lesson has stayed with me for years: the culture of a team is shaped not only by the behavior a leader celebrates, but by the behavior a leader is willing to tolerate.

That makes culture an active leadership responsibility.

What Leaders Ignore Becomes Information

When someone repeatedly dismisses teammates, undermines decisions, withholds information, dominates conversations, or creates fear around disagreement, the rest of the team is watching what happens next.

If nothing happens, that silence communicates something: this behavior is acceptable here.

Leaders don't have to endorse a behavior for it to become part of the culture. Repeatedly tolerating it can have the same effect.

High Performance Doesn't Cancel Harmful Behavior

One of the hardest culture decisions is often what to do when the person creating friction is also a strong performer.

It can be tempting to excuse poor behavior because someone delivers results, has critical expertise, or is difficult to replace. But individual output is only part of performance.

If someone's behavior causes other people to stop contributing, avoid collaboration, withhold concerns, or spend energy navigating the person rather than solving the problem, there is an organizational cost that may not appear on a performance dashboard.

Results matter. So does how those results are achieved.

Psychological Safety Requires Standards

Psychological safety is sometimes misunderstood as creating an environment where people are protected from discomfort or challenge.

I see it differently.

A psychologically safe team should be able to disagree, question decisions, admit mistakes, raise risks, and challenge the work. That requires respectful behavior and clear expectations.

Safety isn't the absence of accountability. Accountability helps create safety because people know the behavioral boundaries apply consistently.

Address Behavior Early and Specifically

Culture problems rarely improve because everyone quietly hopes they will.

When a behavior is getting in the way, leaders need to name it clearly. Useful feedback connects the observable behavior to its impact and explains what needs to change.

That is more actionable than labeling someone as difficult, negative, or not collaborative.

Early conversations also give people a fair opportunity to adjust before frustration accumulates and the behavior becomes part of their reputation.

Trust Comes From Consistency

Teams learn whether to trust leaders by watching whether stated expectations match actual decisions.

If collaboration is a value but the loudest voice always wins, people notice. If respect matters until a top performer violates it, people notice. If leaders ask for candid feedback and then become defensive when they receive it, people notice.

Trust grows when leaders behave predictably around the principles they say matter.

Leaders Have to Model the Standard

Accountability isn't something leaders apply only to other people.

How a leader responds under pressure becomes part of the culture too. Do we listen before reacting? Can someone challenge us? Do we acknowledge when we were wrong? Do we give credit? Do we explain decisions? Do we treat people respectfully when we disagree?

Teams take cues from what leaders do more than from what leaders announce.

Respect Doesn't Mean Avoiding Conflict

Respect is essential to collaboration, but respectful teams aren't conflict-free.

In strong teams, people can challenge assumptions, disagree about priorities, question evidence, and advocate strongly for a different direction without diminishing one another.

Respect means treating the other person as a credible participant in the conversation even when you disagree with their conclusion.

That kind of productive tension is often where better decisions come from.

Culture Is Built in Small Moments

Culture isn't shaped only through major performance conversations or company initiatives. It is reinforced in ordinary moments.

  • Who gets invited into a decision before it is made?

  • What happens when someone raises an uncomfortable risk?

  • Does the team give credit generously?

  • Are quieter voices actively brought into the conversation?

  • Can people admit they don't know something?

  • Are commitments and expectations applied consistently?

  • Does a leader address behavior that undermines the team, even when doing so is uncomfortable?

Those moments accumulate into an understanding of how the team really works.

Protecting Culture Is Part of Leadership

Leaders can't control every interaction on a team, and culture is never created by one person alone.

But leaders have disproportionate influence over the conditions people work within.

We decide what gets reinforced. We decide what deserves a conversation. We decide whether stated values are standards or slogans.

A healthy culture doesn't require everyone to think alike or avoid conflict. It requires enough trust and respect for people to contribute fully, enough clarity to understand what is expected, and enough accountability to protect those conditions when they are challenged.

Culture is what we repeatedly practice.

What we celebrate matters. What we tolerate does too.

Comments


Let’s Connect

Good things often start with a conversation.

​

Whether you’re interested in product and creative leadership, collaboration, photography and art—or simply want to exchange ideas—I’d love to hear from you.

Susan Ripley Logo

© 2026 by Susan Ripley

  • X
  • White LinkedIn Icon
bottom of page